Tubes vs. Transistors in Recording Equipment

“Engineers and musicians have long debated the question of tube sound versus transistor sound.”

From the AES Journal, in the form of a paper first presented in 1972, Russell Hamm delivers a quasi-scientific study and analysis of the difference between tube and solid-state microphone pre-amps.  Click here to read the fourteen-page article. This paper confirms what most recording engineers seem to realize intuitively: solid-state and vacuum tube amplifiers operate equally ‘well’ (read: musically-pleasing) when operated totally clean.  However, Hamm reports that tube microphone pre-amps offer 15 – 20 db more acceptable semi-distorted headroom on transients, while only showing a 2-4 db actual increase in electrical output over this range.  I.E., as Hamm states, tube microphone pre-amps can be extremely effective compressors.  There’s more to it than that; read the piece and draw your own conclusions.

 

 

 

This entry was posted in Technical. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Tubes vs. Transistors in Recording Equipment

  1. Brad Rinkert says:

    The later article Hamm wrote, “Transistors Can Sound Better Than Tubes”, is MUCH tougher to find. I wonder why.

    • Jay McKnight says:

      Nothing evil here: “The later article Hamm wrote, “Transistors Can Sound Better Than Tubes”” is published in the AES Journal, it’s just not free (5 $ for AES members, 20 $ for non-members). Go to “http://www.aes.org”, then to “publications”, then “AES E-Library”, enter “Hamm”, and search.

  2. Jerry Dillon says:

    No, I’m not going to pay $20 to AES for a forty year old article. I’m sorry, I’m not now and am not going to join AES, especially since their conventions are nothing but a phat toob mic pre fest anymore. Nothing but overpriced recording gear. No speakers, no amplifiers, no nothing anymore.

    Copyright duration needs a trimming back. Badly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>